Wednesday, April 28, 2010

RABBI ARTHUR SEGAL: ECO-JUDAISM: WALL STREET + BANKING FRAUD: JEWISH ETHICS

 
RABBI ARTHUR SEGAL: ECO-JUDAISM: WALL STREET + BANKING FRAUD: JEWISH ETHICS
 
Jewish Spiritual Renewal: Shabbat 5/8/10: A Path of Transformation
 
The JEWISH SPIRITUAL RENEWAL CLASS is hosted by Shamash: The Jewish Network A SERVICE OF HEBREW COLLEGE.
 
This week's class is dedicated in the Honor of Mr. Jack (Moshe) Resnick who is finishing his term as President of Congregation Beth Yam. During his tenure many wonderful things occurred by the never- ending chesed of Ha Shem. A beautiful new Synagogue was constructed, and a wonderful God- connected Rabbi,  Brad Bloom, was hired.  May Ha Shem continue to bless you, Moshe, and may you go from strength to strength....michayil el chayil.
 
Shalom Dear Talmidim, Chaverim v' Rabbanim:
 
May you all have a happy Lag B' Omer this Sunday Eve, May 1, 2010. In previous classes I have gone into the spiritual lessons of this holiday, from the studying of Zohar in memory of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, the traditional author of these books of Kabbalah, to having bon fires and BBQs, to remembering the 24,000 rabbis and students of Rabbi Akiva who died because they did not show each other respect, each thinking their learning, and their teachers and their Semikha - ordination were better than the others'.
 
There is also, again, a double Torah portion, with two d'vrai Torah at the close of this week's class. They are both so timely, with the hearings going on in DC re Wall Street and Banking fraud. Our Torah and Talmud addresses these very issues, millennia ago.
 
For those of you near to me in Hilton Head Island, SC, keep Shavuot   morning of May 19, 2010 (Wednesday) on your calendar and come to Beth Yam. Ellen and I commissioned a rabbinic - sofer- scribe to produce a gorgeous Megillah Ruth, that is read, as you know, in synagogues world over on Shavuot, and we dedicated it in the honor of Rabbi and Rebitzin Brad and Linda Bloom, and ALL of the congregants of Beth Yam.  God willing you  will see this beautiful Holy object, see it dedicated it to the Temple, placed in the Aron Kodesh, and hear it read   with the proper Megillah reading blessings. The evening before, erev Shavuot, those that wish, can come to our home for Tikkun Leil Shavuot, all night study. as we do annually.
 
Ok, to this week's class. To those new to the class, you can access last week's class, and from there work back with links to the first class, at
 
Ironically I am writing this class on the 14th of Iyar, April 28, 2010. One month ago on the Jewish Calendar was Passover. And today as I have taught you in the past, is Pesach Sheni, the second Passover. It is tradition to have a bit of Matzah today as well.
 
From a Jewish Spiritual Renewal view point, "Pesach Sheini" is a reminder that we are always given "another chance."  God gives us the opportunity and ability to accomplish the mitzvoth and good deeds which we may have missed earlier in life.  In other words, as we have learned in the class and the book that it is based on, the gates of Teshuvah, of renewal, are always open to us.

 

The Talmud Bavli Tractate Avodah Zarah  17a tells a story about Eleazar ben Durdaya, who committed many sins in his life.  One day someone told him, that even if he repented, God will not accept it.  He went and sat between two hills and exclaimed: "Hills and mountains, plead for mercy for me!" They replied: "How can we pray for you, when we have to pray for ourselves?"  He then exclaimed: "Heaven and earth, plead for mercy for me!" They replied: "How shall we pray for you, when we stand in need of prayer ourselves!"  He then exclaimed: "Sun and moon, plead for mercy for me!" But they also replied: "How shall we pray for thee, when we stand in need of it ourselves!"  He then exclaimed: "Stars and constellations plead for mercy for me!"  But they too said, "How can we pray for you, we stand in need of it ourselves!"   R. Eleazar ben Durdaya said: "The matter then depends upon me alone!"

 

While God helps us, Jewish Spiritual Renewal has to be done by us. No one can do it for us. Renewal is not for people who need it, it is for people who want it.

 

He placed his head between his knees and wept aloud so much until his soul departed! A voice from heaven proclaiming: "Rabbi Eleazar ben Durdaya is destined for the life of the World-to-Come!"

 

The Talmud continues that Rabbi Yehuda Ha Nasi, upon hearing this, wept and said: "One can acquire Eternal Life after many years; while another in one hour!  Rabbi Yehuda also said: "Not only are the people who repent accepted, they are even called Rabbi!''

 

Today as I write on Pesach Sheini,, I am again reminded that  God never gives up on us.  He always gives us another chance.  It is us who give up on God. And as we have learned and are continuing to learn, as Buber taught, when we reach out our hand and ask God to take it, we will find that His loving Hands are there waiting for us. And while the above parable talks about the World to Come, our lives on earth change to a living heaven, when we renew our selves spiritually.

 

Please remember the teaching of Rabbi Simchah Bunim of Peshischa:  A person should have two pockets in his coat. One should contain the Talmudic saying, "A person is commanded to maintain: For my sake was the world created." In the second pocket he should keep the verse, "I am but dust and ashes." Stay humble. Our renewal is not a badge we wear on our sleeves. Our actions of kindness, the changes others see in us, will at some point help them renew. We are in no way better than others. This path is open to all.


 

We can't solve problems by using the same kind of thinking we used when we created the problems. Jewish Spiritual Renewal gives our lives a paradigm shift and allows us to control our past 'monkey brains,' and to think clearly, trust in God, and act with righteousness and unceasing love.  

 

Our rabbis taught that there is no such thing as spiritual defeat. There is always another chance. To believe in defeat is to believe that there is something, a certain point in time that did not come from Above. Know that God doesn't have failures. If things appear to worsen, it is only because part of them are getting better. We only fall down in order to bounce back even higher.

 
Allow me to end,  before we go into the text and then the d'vrai Torah with a short teaching from Rabbi Shlomo Carlebach. ''Let me tell you something. Our holy rabbis teach us, sadness makes you so dirty. I don't know what it is… it is a spirit of uncleanliness, a spirit of unholiness, that descends upon you. And believe me friends, most friendships break because there is not enough joy in the world. And here, I want you to know something. Rav Nachman says, why are you so sad? Because everything goes wrong in your life. But gevalt, gevalt, do you know why everything goes wrong? Because you are so sad. But again, my friends, you will ask me; 'I am so sad. How do I get happy?' Believe me, I wish I would know the answer. I can only bless you… I can only bless you, that God should give you the gift of joy. Friends, life is in the hands of God, joy is in the hands of God. And God is giving joy to those who He feels fit. And even if you are not fit – misfits like you and I – there is only one way… there is only one way… there is only one way; to pray and to pray… To pray and to pray. Friends, you pray for everything. But you know what Reb Nachman says? Every second, every split second, you have to ask God and cry and beg; 'Please God, let my heart be filled with joy.''
 
And so let us learn more about prayer, especially the entreaty types of prayer, Rabbi Carlebach is referring to above. Let us learn to live happy, joyous and free.


 
 

Bakashah: Prayers of Petition

Now, let's look at entreaties. These prayers are petitions through which we make requests of God. The Hebrew word for entreaty is "bakashah." Note that this has the same root as the Hebrew word for please, which is be'vakashah. We see these in our prayer books (sidurim) asking God for "rain in its season," or good health (mi sheberach), and always for peace. Keep in mind that you should never pray for your own selfish reasons. Even when praying to God for healing, you are asking Him to do so that you can make your life a blessing and continue doing His will. On the other hand, it is vain to ask God for a new Mercedes Benz just because your friends all have Porsches. You can always pray that God help others though. That is quite unselfish.

Jeremiah in Chapter 17, Verse 13 gives us advice for bakashah. "The Hope of Israel (Mickve Israel) is God." He teaches us not to depend of our fellow frail man's ways but to trust in God's teachings. In the next verse (17:14) we read what has become our mi sheberach prayer in our Amidah: "Heal me, God, and I will be healed; save me, and I will be saved."

Rabbi Alexandri's prayer in Talmud Bavli Tractate Beracoth 17a is: "May it be your will, Lord our God, to place us in an illuminated corner and not to place us in a darkened corner. Let not our heart be sick nor our eyes darkened." His prayer was all about God helping him become the best spiritual Jew and person that he could be, for the sake of God and be spiritually awakened.

 

Becky and Myron decided to take their little son from the heat of the city to his first visit to the beach. Dressed in his little sailor suit and hat with pail and shovel in hand, the boy happily played at the water's edge as his mother and father spread their picnic blanket. Then suddenly, to his parents' horror, a huge wave crashed down on the boy and then dragged him far out to sea. As neither of his parents could swim, his mother began to wail and cry, "Dear God, be merciful. Return our son to us!"

Suddenly another huge wave cast the boy back up on the sand at his parents' feet. His mother inspected her son and then quickly looked back towards the heavens and said, "He had a hat!"

 

 

Next week, B'H, well will work on the third part of the Chapter 8 , which deals with tephila, prayers of self judgement. Two d'vari Torah follow as the Shabbat for May 8, 2010 is a double portion.
 
Shalom u'vracha:
 
Rabbi Arthur Segal
Via Shamash Org on-line class service
Jewish Renewal
www.jewishrenewal.info
Jewish Spiritual Renewal
www.jewishspiritualrenewal.org
Jewish Spirituality
Eco Judaism
Hilton Head Island, SC, Bluffton, SC, Savannah, GA
 

Parasha Behar: Leviticus 25:01-26:02

Rabbi Arthur Segal
Via Shamash Org on-line class service
Jewish Renewal
www.jewishrenewal.info
Jewish Spiritual Renewal
www.jewishspiritualrenewal.org
Jewish Spirituality
Eco Judaism
Hilton Head Island, SC, Bluffton, SC, Savannah, GA

"Ribbit, Ribbit"

Two Budweiser Frogs were visiting Eretz, Israel. It was a beautiful evening on Lake Kinneret in Ha Galilee. Yakov was feeling amorous. He said to Rivka, "Ribbit?"

There was no reply. Yakov waited a few moments are tried again. "Ribbit?"

But again there was silence. Yakov, frustrated, puffed out his big bullfrog chest and bellowed "RIBBIT!"

Rivka coolly replied, "I'm not INTERESTed."

Ribbit is the Hebrew word for interest – the monetary kind. "If your brother becomes impoverished...you shall strengthen him - stranger or resident - so that he can live with you. Do not take from him interest and increase. Do not give him your money for interest, and do not give your food for increase." (Lev 25:35-37).

These same commandments are echoed in Deuteronomy 23:20-21 with a twist. "You shall not cause your brother to take interest, interest of money or interest of food, interest of anything that he may take as interest. You may cause a gentile to take interest, but you may not cause your brother to take interest."

Ribbit is the lending of money for interest. A Jew is not allowed to charge interest. This prohibition not only extends to monetary loans, but also to transactions involving barter or delayed payments. No one is to derive a financial benefit by waiting to receive payment or property. A Jew is not allowed to pay interest either. The Talmudic rabbis actually forbade certain transactions because they had the appearance of interest, even though the law was not actually violated. These are called "ha'aramat ribbit."

The society promulgated by the Torah did not want to wait until someone became poor to help him. We are commanded to help one as soon as he begins to lose money. We are not to wait until he becomes poor. The Chazal (the rabbis of the Talmudic period of 500 C.E.) said, "Uphold him before he falls and becomes dependent of charity." Maimonides ruled that one of the highest forms of charity is to help another before he becomes destitute and has to ask for help. The Rambam said we could do this with free loans, investing in his business, offers of employment, or any other assistance. This mitzvah comes from the phrase "you shall strengthen him." Rashi offers the analogy of when we see a donkey beginning to lose its load, we are to rush in and help. If we wait until the load totally falls off the donkey's back, it will take five times the effort to correct the situation.

The Torah uses two words for interest and increase. The word "neshek" comes from the word "neshehkah," which means, "biting." The transaction bites into the borrower's wealth. The second word, ribbit, means to increase, as this is what happens to the lender's wealth. The Torah disallows both. But why in Leviticus do we see that the law applies to both Jew and non-Jew, but in Deuteronomy we see that Jews can charge non-Jews interest and conversely pay non-Jews interest? Did God change his mind? Or could it be that Deuteronomy was written at a later time, perhaps during the period of Ezra (circa 500 B.C.E.) after the return from Babylon, when many rules were enacted delineating Jew from non-Jew. An example of this would be Ezra's ruling that all returning Jews to Israel must divorce their non-Jewish wives. Could this be another law keeping us from social intercourse with gentiles?

If we could borrow interest-free from a fellow Jew, why would we consider borrowing from a non-Jew? But on the other hand, if we could get interest from a non-Jew, why would we consider helping a Jew from who we could not make ribbit? Perhaps the answer is found in the next verse where we are taught that God will bless us in our undertakings. Is this saying that our willingness to forgo financial gain by borrowing and lending only from Jews is what God considers just?

Maimonides insists that taking interest from a non-Jew is a positive commandment. The Rambam wrote that this indeed would limit our interacting with them and hence limit intermarriage. He believed that if Jews gave gentiles interest-free loans, they would become grateful to us, socialize with us, and we would adopt their ways and marry their children.

The Talmud Bavli is replete with verses concerning ribbit. Chapter 5 of Tractate Bava Metziah is dedicated to the subject. Tractates Succah 29A and Temurah 6B list the punishments for lending or paying interest and actually compare lending with interest to murder. Interestingly, Tractate Makkot 24A says that while it is kosher to lend to a non-Jew with interest, there is value and goodness in lending to him without financial gain.

But there is another Torah verse often overlooked regarding this subject. In Exodus 22:24 we read, "When you lend money to My people, to the poor person who is with you, do not act toward him as a creditor and do not lay interest upon him." This law immediately follows the mitzvoth to take care of the stranger, widow, and orphan, Jew or non-Jew. Does "My people" (ah-me) mean Jews only or all of God's people are deserving of care when in need? It is obvious from the content of this paragraph that the authors of the Torah laws in Exodus and Leviticus prohibited all people in need from being charged interest.

Note that loans with prohibited interest had to do with helping the poor in an agrarian society. The idea of commercial loans was a city innovation. One took out a loan only in desperation during the time of the formation of our people. We were commanded not to take advantage of the poor. That is what interest to a poor person would be. It would be cruel to require a destitute person to pay interest when the loan itself would be difficult enough to pay back. This law also teaches us that we should trust that God is in absolute control over us and our possessions. The money that we lend is not our money at all. It is God's money and He has lent it to us. To loan without interest is to have the same faith in God when we do not work on Shabbat and when we do not plow in the Sabbatical (shemittah) year. These rules are also in this parasha in Lev. 25:4,11.

However, when some of us returned from the exile in Babylon, commerce had to resume quickly. There had to be a free flow of money. The laws were slightly changed to adapt to those times. When some of our people returned to Judea under the orders of the Persian king, Cyrus, we were lead by Prince Sheshbazzar, the son of Jehoichin, the next-to-last king of Judah. When Jehoichin was released from prison by Nebuchadnezzar's successor he and his family became quite wealthy. Some of these wealthy Jews became aristocrats in the Persian court. They had little financial incentive to return to Judea. In fact most Jews decided to stay in Babylon and live as Talmudic Rabbinic Jews, and not again as Temple Priest oriented Hebrews.

A parallel development was occurring in Egypt. A group of Jewish businessmen established themselves circa 650 B.C.E. on the Elephantine Island in the Nile River near the present day Aswan dam. They had commercial contact with the Jews of Persia for 200 years. They had their own temple where they offered animal sacrifices just as in Jerusalem. They did this long after the first Temple was destroyed by the Babylonians. Jews were no longer tied to the land as farmers and shepherds. They were merchants and bankers and needed to use capital and have it work for them. They needed to charge interest to the non-Jews who wanted investment monies, and they needed to pay interest to non-Jews when Jews needed investment money.

As a historical note that you may find fascinating, Rabbi Raymond Scheindlin writes of the Judean authorities after Ezra. They built the Second Temple and then tried to shut down the Elephantine Temple as it ran contrary to Deuteronomy 12:4-9 by having a private altar. It functioned until 410 B.C.E. when some Egyptians rebelled against the Persians, and the Jews remained loyal to the Persians. The neighboring priests of the ram-god Khnum took the opportunity to destroy the temple, as they were offended because the Jews sacrificed sheep and rams. When the Persians suppressed the Egyptian rebellion, they rewarded the Jews of Elephantine Island by allowing them to rebuild their temple. However to bow to both the Cohanim in Jerusalem's second Temple and the Egyptian priests who worshipped rams, the Jewish Elephantine Temple could only sacrifice vegetables, fruits, and grains. The colony disappeared 100 years later. This is yet another example of Jews adapting and reforming to meet their needs and situations, while still remaining Jewish.

The Bible records how only a few Jews obeyed the Jubilee year rules. These rules, listed in Lev. 25:10-11, state that every 50 years, all deeds to land revert back to the original owner. This rule was altered as well with a loophole saying that it only applied when 100 percent of all the tribes lived in Israel. Since some had vanished, the law was voided until their return. (Talmud Bavli Tractate Arachin 32B).

Interest, Proverbs 23:32 says, is like the "bite of a snake that bursts and increases." Regardless of these economic matters, our goal as modern Jews is to always remember the Torah's principles of concession, good-heartedness, and performing ahavath chesed (deeds of loving kindness). Proverbs also says that the Torah's "ways are pleasant, and all her paths peaceful." (3:17). When we study Torah, Talmud, and Mishna we must never lose sight of this primary demand.

Chapter 5 of Talmud Bavli Tractate Bava Metzia begins by asking what the difference is between interest and increase. Daf 60B concludes that the words are synonymous with subtle differences between Torah interest and Talmudic interest. The major difference is that Torah interest is recoverable by going to court. The study of rabbinic interest, called the dust of ribbit, is fascinating. It is Talmudically not allowed for the borrower to do a favor for or to honor the lender. He cannot invite him over for dinner, get him an aliyah at the synagogue, or let him stay overnight rent-free in his home. These could all be construed to be ribbit. A seller cannot charge more for an object if one defers payment. Conversely one cannot charge less if one pays cash for an item on the barrelhead.

Insincere transactions are prohibited as well by the Talmud. For example, Moses lent money on the security of Aaron's field worth more than the loan. The contract said that if Aaron did not pay back the loan, Moses would own the field. At the time of the contract both Aaron and Moses knew that Aaron would not pay back the loan, and Moses would end up with the field, which was worth more than the loan. This increase would be illegal ribbit. The contract is based on the reliance that the condition of repayment will not be met. This fraud is called an "asmachta" from the Hebrew word for "reliance."

Here is where the Talmud begins to answer the question of the double standard of Jew and non-Jew vis-à-vis interest. Bava Metzia 70B quotes a sage from the Second Temple days who prohibited lending money to gentiles with interest even though the Torah in Deuteronomy 23:21 says it is all right. The reason is so that we would have no dealings with them and learn from their ways. Remember, non-Jews then were pagans and the term gentile did not mean Christian as we commonly use the term today. An exception was given to Torah scholars who would not, it was assumed, succumb to pagan ideas.

A rabbi from the Mishna period 200 C.E. ruled that the Torah law of loaning to a resident alien (ger) without interest was to be interpreted so that the ger would be treated the same as a gentile and charged interest. Why? Unlike Torah times when we lived with a mixed multitude of people in our midst in relative peace, in 200 C.E. Jews lived with pagan Roman conquerors who were both resident aliens and gentiles. But by the time the chapter ends we read in daf 75B that the more liberal rabbis of the Talmud period in 500 C.E. posited that the law of  "before a blind man you shall not place a stumbling block" (Lev 19:14) clearly refers to all men. They go on to say that one should not cause another to sin.

Desperate people are like the blind. Since it is a sin to charge or pay interest, it would be a sin to lead a gentile into taking out a loan and paying interest. Therefore, they reason, it is best to neither charge nor pay interest to anyone, Jew or non-Jew.

We have seen how it is easy to interpret the Torah's rules to mean that one should help the poor of any people with interest-free loans and any way possible. We can see how the Torah was not speaking of commercial loans. However, since this was not stated specifically, an elaborate legal fiction had to be set up to allow Jews to engage in commerce as the world became modernized.

Before the modernity of the world abutted with Halakah (Jewish law), Jews struggled through the Middle Ages. Many anti-Jewish laws were devised to keep us from owning homes or property and from engaging in trades that required joining guilds. The Church had Canon law based on our Torah, which forbade Christians from charging interest. They called it usury, from the Latin word for use. Today the legal term usury means charging above the fixed interest rate. However at that time it simply meant charging interest. Christians could not charge interest to each other based on Canon law. The Church needed Jews to be their bankers because the Church interpreted Deuteronomy's verses to mean that Jews could lend to Christians. In 1179, Pope Alexander III issued a ban prohibiting all Christians from lending money with interest to anyone. He cited Luke 6:35: "Love your enemies, and do good, and lend, expecting nothing in return."

The Church ruled that this ban did not apply to Jews, as we were not "true believers." This is a biblical interpretation of acting as if the shoe is on the other foot. As noted in our discussion of the Jews of the Babylonian and Roman diasporas, Jews traveled from country to country buying and selling merchandise. Credit was unheard of and cash was the only means of payment. If a Jew needed money he could not get it from a Christian, as a Christian could not lend to him with interest. So Jews were forced to borrow from and lend to each other. But the Torah mitzvah of not collecting interest put the Jewish bankers at a disadvantage. The rabbis devised a legal fiction that gave Jews permission to break Torah laws to protect their financial livelihoods. Since financial livelihood affects one's life, they were allowed to break the laws of ribbit on the grounds that they were fulfilling the mitzvah of saving a life.

The Jews would lend their money from benches near cathedrals and churches in town squares. They could charge and collect interest as the rabbis ruled that this was a permissible venture (hetter iska). The Italian word for bench is "banco" and this is from where our English word "bank" is derived. The Church developed a legal fiction as well, because they taxed the Jewish moneylenders heavily. So while the Church was not collecting interest from their fellow Christians directly, they were doing so indirectly. Of course, as history shows, the Jews were blamed for extracting a "pound of flesh," as Shakespeare wrote about Shylock, the Jewish moneylender in his play, The Merchant of Venice.

The concept of a Jewish permissible venture was devised. This is called in Hebrew a hetter iska, which is, according to Professor Steven Resnicoff, Esq., "a unique contractual arrangement devised under Jewish law to circumvent the religious prohibition on the collection or payment of interest. It accomplishes this by substituting an investment scheme in lieu of a loan without meaningfully altering the parties' respective rights. Within the realm of Jewish law, this device for centuries has facilitated effectively consumer as well as commercial financing."

To explain the legal workings of this permissible venture would take pages and would read like a law text. It is recognized Halachically as a "shutfus," which is loosely translated as a partnership. Under Jewish law a person can invest in and share the profits of a shutfus without being personally liable for any loss. Moreover, one member of a shutfus is not necessarily authorized to bind another personally. Nor may one member of a shutfus be liable for acts of another. Therefore one can set up this dummy partnership, with A giving B money, B using the money with A having no say in its use and no liability for B's losses or mistakes. And yet A can sit back, not be involved, and be paid back his investment and a share of the profits. According to Jewish law, this money is neither principal nor interest.

What happens when Jewish law, which defends this legal fiction, collides against U.S. law, which despises, as did our Talmudic rabbis, contrived contracts (asmachta)? In the 1985 case of Bollag v. Dresdner, the court considered a case where the financier (lender) gave the recipient (borrower) $15,000 to be used for business purposes. Soon thereafter, the parties signed a Jewish permissible venture agreement stipulating the amount, the terms, and the conditions of the arrangement. The agreement stated that the recipient received $15,000 for a business investment from which the recipient would share his profit with the financier. The court concluded that substance, not form, controlled characterization of the venture, noting that, "a transaction must be considered in its totality and judged by its real character, rather than by the name, color, or form which the parties assign to it." It therefore ruled that the transaction was a loan with interest and not an investment.

In reaching its conclusion, the court took into consideration the financier's statement that he was not to share in any business losses of the recipient but that his investment was unconditionally guaranteed. In addition, the court heard a rabbi as an expert witness who said that Jewish permissible contracts were not loan agreements. The court concluded that these contracts are indeed loan agreements and that the rabbi and the financier were being disingenuous.

By calling loans partnerships, those who are trying to get around the mitzvoth of not charging and accepting interest are putting themselves in legal jeopardy. They are potentially breaking the laws of tax deductions, interest declaration, tax reporting, partnership frauds, bank fraud, revised uniform limited partnerships, as well as the Torah law of not stealing, lying, and swearing false oaths. This has caused some states, like New Jersey, to demand that all consumer contracts be drafted in language that may be understood plainly by the general public.

 The biggest sin the users of these permissible ventures commit is breaking the mitzvah of chillul ha Shem (desecration of God's name, which we learned about in the previous d'var Torah) by making our people appear fraudulent by looking for loopholes to disobey our own civil and religious laws and cheat others.

The spirit of the Torah law is to help people in their time of need without abusing them. As spiritual Jews we have the benefit of being able to study and discern this. We can say without fear of rebuke or excommunication that we wish to set up free loan societies to help the poor of our community, while at the same time not having to engage in legal fictions to lend or borrow money for commercial uses. This is the mitzvah of "gemilut chesed." The law to extend chesed (kindness) as ordained by the Torah makes no distinction between friend and foe.

Exodus 23:04 tells us to return even our enemy's ox if we find it. We are supposed to help our enemy if his mule is overburdened. Talmud Bavli Tractate Bava Metzia 31A states that we are obliged to help him 100 times over. To not give a free loan to a non-Jew in need would be like bearing a grudge, which is also a sin. By performing legalistic routines to avoid mitzvoth we are missing out on the joy of Torah's spiritual teachings. When we are taught in Leviticus 25:35 to help the poor so he can live with us (umatatah yado imach), we are being taught that we are all connected as people. "Imach" means "together with you." When there are poor in our community it is not only bad for them, but bad for the society in general and us as individuals. When the Torah says "vehechezakta bo," the actual translation means you shall "strengthen in him," not "strengthen him."

Rabbi Yehoshua says in the Mishna Rabba Vayikra, "more than the rich does for the poor, the poor does for the rich." When all members of society are no longer poor, we all become richer.

When we are taught not to take interest so we can "let your brother live with you," we are being told that God wants harmony to exist. The lender who extracts interest hopes that the loan is extended as he earns money on each passing day. The lender wants to gain wealth so he can repay the loan quickly and save on interest. But when one is lent money with no interest, both have the same goals of a quick repayment due to financial recovery of the borrower. The Shulchan Aruk in its Halachic rules on ribbit (160:2) goes so far as to say that one who charges interest denies the Exodus from Egypt. These are some of the spiritual gems the Torah and Talmud and other texts are trying to teach us.

Talmud Bavli Tractate Shabbat 133B says, "Imitate God. As He is gracious and merciful, so you be gracious and merciful." If a poor person, Jew or non-Jew, needs help, do we break the commandment of not "standing idly by the blood of your neighbor" and not help the non-Jew as we would the Jew? Do we forget the spirit of the Torah and spend more time on legal fictions to lend to each other with interest on commercial loans, and ignore the plight of our fellow humans who need interest-free loans just to get back on their feet? Do we ignore Deuteronomy 15:7-8 where it says, "If there be a destitute person among you...you shall not harden your heart or close your hand. Rather, you shall open your hand to him, you shall lend him what he needs?" I think not.

Parasha Bechukotai: Leviticus 26:03-27:34

Rabbi Arthur Segal
Via Shamash Org on-line class service
Jewish Renewal
www.jewishrenewal.info
Jewish Spiritual Renewal
www.jewishspiritualrenewal.org
Jewish Spirituality
Eco Judaism
Hilton Head Island, SC, Bluffton, SC, Savannah, GA

"You hold the key to love and fear all in your trembling hand. Just one key unlocks them both. Its there at your command"

This parasha ends the Book of Leviticus. If there has been a recurring motif in this book it has been "Kedoshim Tih'yu - You shall be holy." We have discussed in d'vrai Torah the many ways of achieving holiness, spirituality and a set-aside feeling. In this Parasha Bechukotai, translated as "My Decrees," we read how God promised blessings if we work toward holiness and promised curses if we do not. These curses, called "tochachah" (admonitions), are so horrendous that in many traditional synagogues they are whispered when the Torah portion is read. An abridged version of the blessings and curses are repeated in Deuteronomy Chapter 11. This makes up part of the Shema prayer in traditional sidurim (prayer books), but has been deleted from some liberal prayer books.

The liberal movements do not adhere to the traditional notion of reward and punishment by God. They do accept the idea of God as the true judge. They acknowledge that His judgment is not always understandable or discernible. We know that bad things do happen to good people. We also know that good things happen to bad people. However, how do we know who is truly bad and who is sincerely good? Those judgments are better left to God. We as Jews are correctly taught not to judge our fellows.

The emotional "grime" in which we find ourselves wallowing is punishment enough for those of us who have drifted away from holiness. Our Midrash says in Deuteronomy Rabbah 2:12 that "the gates of repentance are always open." Psychiatrist Carl Jung wrote in his Collected Letters (Vol. I, page 162) that "no one who is a Jew can become a human being without knowing that he is a Jew, since this is the basis from which he can reach out to a higher humanity." In other words, the joy of living justly is its own reward.

As Jews who have a code of ethics to follow, the guilt that we feel inside when we ignore our mandate is punishment enough. As King David said in Psalm 16:07, "I bless God who is my counselor, but in the night, my inmost self instructs me." The authors of the Torah and our great sages can only teach us. It is we who must study, choose and follow. Even for those who wish to live their lives without divine ethical guidance, at some point will understand the verse from Genesis 4:10, "Your brother's blood is calling out from the ground." When that realization comes to one who has lived with little spirituality, it is tochachah enough. That person is ready for the teshuvah of Jewish Spiritual Renewal.

If God had not commanded us to obey His mitzvoth, would we have an ethical imperative to behave properly? We know the concept of the seven Noahide Laws from Genesis that all men are commanded to obey. They parallel the Ten Commandments minus Shabbat and honoring one's parents. The "God Laws" are combined. Are these ethics independent of Halakah (Jewish law)? And are ethics built into our system of Jewish laws? Many traditional views say no. We do as God commands and if ethical behavior is a benefit, fantastic. The liberal Jewish view however gives a resounding yes to both questions.

On the seal of my Alma Mater, the University of Pennsylvania, it is written, "Leges sin more vanae," "laws without morals are vanity." Since the Torah does allow us to drink wine and eat certain meat, does this mean we are allowed to be drunkards and gluttons? Maimonides clearly says that there must be an ethic independent of the Torah as we must abstain or do in moderation those things that Torah did not expressly forbid.

There is a command: "and you shall do what is right and good in the eyes of God." Rabbi Elazar ben Azariah talks numerous times in the Talmud of the value assigned to doing good outside of the context of a specific mitzvah. As spiritual Jews we do not do good for the sake of a reward. We do it because it is the right and moral thing to do.

 When we do something not good we do teshuvah (repentance, returning, renewal). This is not because we are afraid of the curses we read in this portion, but because we each accept voluntarily the moral imperative to correct our wrongs. We do not live our lives obsessing over reward and punishment.

Our self-definition from Talmud Bavli Tractate Yevamot 79A sums up our views: "We are compassionate ones and bestowers of kindness." We might be eating pork if we were not commanded not to do so, but we certainly would not be committing murder if we were not commanded to not do so. This is one reason why the liberal rabbis deleted the verses of curses and blessings from their prayer books.

Liberal Jews have proclaimed themselves to be not bound by ritual halakah. However, we strongly embrace the anthropo-mitzvoth. We, as we discussed a few parashot ago, must truly love our neighbors as ourselves. We have an obligation to go beyond the law when it comes to man-to-man obligations and behaviors.

Rabbi Yohanan said in Talmud Bavli Tractate Bava Metzia 30B that Jerusalem in 70 C.E. was destroyed because people followed "din Torah" (the Law of the Torah). He explained that they followed the letter of the law, but not the spirit of the law. They did not practice "lifnim mi Shurat ha Din" (beyond the letter of the Law).

They were destroyed. It is not just correct for a Jew to do ritual minutia while ignoring the plight of those around him. That would be keeping to the letter of the law, but not to the spirit. When we endeavor to keep to the spirit of the law, we progress toward holiness. We help fulfill the theme of Leviticus of Kedoshim Tih'yu (you shall be holy).

As we have seen, Jews have an obligation to go beyond the letter of the law. Our essence as Jung describes it is to know what it means to be a Jew. We have an obligation to study and to reason and not just to follow blindly. In Talmud Bavli Tractate Sanhedrin 74A, Rabbi Rava renders an opinion concerning the man who was given a choice to kill or be killed. Rava tells the man to allow himself to be killed because "who says your blood is redder than his?" The other rabbis agree with Rava even though no scripture is quoted. This is referred to as "s'vara," literally reasoning. Jewish reasoning, as Rabbi Y. Etshalom writes, "is the reasonable result of ethical and religious norms inculcated in Jewish culture and society."

Jewish tradition has always respected and valued life for its own sake. It is not just enough to be right; we must be good. We must not only follow the mitzvoth outlining our behaviors toward our fellows, we must go beyond them.

The Ba'al Shem Tov, founder of the Chassidic movement, wrote, "For the want of the thing that you lack is in the indwelling Glory. For man is a part of God, and the want that is in the part is in the whole, and the whole suffers the want of the part. Therefore, let your prayer be directed to the want of the Whole."

When we are connected to the Divine Presence by holy acts, we are dwelling with God. The word for this presence, the Sheckinah, comes from the Hebrew shin-kuf-nun (to dwell). When we do our best to strive for holy spirituality we bring forth the Ruach Kodesh, the Holy Spirit.

 The ultimate enlightenment of humanity is when we all act compassionately and lovingly toward one another according to Rabbi Aryeh Kaplan. This is when God will "pour out His Holy Spirit on all flesh." (Joel 2:28). Please note that the idea of the Holy Spirit is not Christian in origin. It is a Jewish concept borrowed by St. Paul (Rabbi Saul) in his development of the theology of the Godhead.

So from where do our blessings come? Where should we place our hope? Jeremiah in Chapter 17, Verse 13 from this week's Haftarah gives us the answer. "The Hope of Israel (Mickve Israel) is God." He teaches us not to depend of our fellow frail man's ways but to trust in God's teachings. In a later verse (17:14) we read what has become a prayer in our Amidah: "Heal me, God, and I will be healed; save me, and I will be saved."

Some of the first Jews who came to what is now the State of Georgia, USA in 1733, placed their faith in God. They believed that they were partners with God. They named their Congregation Mickve Israel - the Hope of Israel. It is the third oldest congregation in the United States and is located in Savannah, Georgia.

We ask God to help us, but we must also help ourselves. We ask God to heal us, but we must also heal ourselves. We ask God to grant us "rain in our season" (Lev. 26:04), but we must plant the seeds. We are the ones who are God's co-workers in Tikun Olam, the repair of the world.

By striving to do justice, do good deeds, act kindly and lovingly, with hope and trust in God, we hopefully will avoid the tochachah's disasters described in this parasha.

Shabbat Shalom:

Rabbi Arthur Segal
Via Shamash Org on-line class service
Jewish Renewal
www.jewishrenewal.info
Jewish Spiritual Renewal
www.jewishspiritualrenewal.org
Jewish Spirituality
Eco Judaism
Hilton Head Island, SC, Bluffton, SC, Savannah, GA

 


The SPIRITUALRENEWAL mailing list is hosted by Shamash: The Jewish Network.
Join Shamash's Groups on Facebook and LinkedIn.


To unsubscribe email SPIRITUALRENEWAL-unsubscribe-request@SHAMASH.ORG
For other options go to: http://listserv.SHAMASH.ORG/